Windstar Star Breeze vs. Paul Gauguin Cruises – Tahiti Luxury Cruise Comparison 2025

🛳️ Windstar Star Breeze vs. Paul Gauguin Cruises – Tahiti Luxury Cruise Comparison 2025 🌺

Planning a luxury escape to the South Pacific paradise in 2025? Choosing the right ship is crucial, and the Windstar Star Breeze and Paul Gauguin Cruises are two of the top contenders. Both cruise lines offer unforgettable experiences in Tahiti and the surrounding islands, but with distinct styles and levels of inclusion. From ship size and onboard ambiance to cabin types, all-inclusive value, and cultural experiences, this detailed comparison will help you discover which one best suits your style and expectations for a dream cruise in French Polynesia.

🚢 Ship Size & Guest Experience

The Windstar Star Breeze, with a capacity of up to 312 guests, boasts a relaxed, yacht-like ambiance with ample space. Onboard areas are generous, and the relationship with the crew is personal, facilitating an intimate and uncrowded cruise experience. On the other hand, Paul Gauguin Cruises, hosting 332 guests aboard the m/s Paul Gauguin, is renowned for its authentic Polynesian atmosphere. This is enhanced by the presence of the “Les Gauguines” team—local women who offer authentic cultural activities, dance performances, and language lessons, adding a distinct immersive touch. Both ships are small, allowing them access to ports inaccessible to larger vessels, but the difference in ambiance is notable.

🛏️ Cabins & Comfort

Aboard the Windstar Star Breeze, all accommodations are considered suites and are among the most spacious in the region, starting at 277 square feet. However, it’s important to note that most do not feature full private balconies; many offer “French balconies” (floor-to-ceiling sliding doors that open, but without an outdoor space to sit) or large picture windows. Certain higher-category suites do provide genuine balconies. In contrast, Paul Gauguin’s cabins are generally smaller, starting at around 200 square feet, but the majority include a real private balcony, ideal for enjoying spectacular ocean views and private outdoor relaxation. The choice here depends on your priority: generous interior space or a guaranteed private outdoor balcony.

💰 All-Inclusive Value

This is an area where Paul Gauguin Cruises truly shines: their fares are genuinely all-inclusive, covering gratuities, beverages (including premium alcoholic drinks), Wi-Fi, and most watersports from the ship’s marina. This means your vacation budget will be much more predictable, with few additional onboard costs. On the other hand, Windstar Star Breeze’s fares are more à la carte. While the base price may seem lower, you’ll pay extra for most drinks (excluding water, coffee, and tea), Wi-Fi, and gratuities. However, Windstar often offers promotional packages that may include some of these benefits, so it’s crucial to check the offer details. For a financially worry-free experience, Paul Gauguin is often the clear choice.

🍽️ Dining & Cuisine

Both cruise lines pride themselves on high-end cuisine, but differences emerge in terms of inclusions. Aboard Paul Gauguin, all specialty restaurants are included in the cruise fare, with no extra charges. This allows guests to explore a variety of flavors, from refined French cuisine to fresh Polynesian dishes, without any financial concerns. Windstar Star Breeze, on the other hand, receives excellent reviews for the quality of its culinary offerings, especially for events like the Deck Barbecue under the stars and special themed nights. However, some specialty dining experiences or certain beverages may incur additional costs. Both ships prioritize fresh ingredients and a memorable gastronomic experience, but Paul Gauguin offers greater cost flexibility in its specialty restaurants.

🗺️ Itineraries & Destinations

Both cruise lines cover iconic destinations like Tahiti, Bora Bora, and the Society Islands. However, there are notable differences in extended routes. Windstar Star Breeze is known for its flexibility and ability to make rare and unexpected stops in the Marquesas Islands, offering a more adventurous and less tourist-heavy experience. These routes can be a strong point for explorers seeking authenticity. On the other hand, Paul Gauguin’s sailings often extend to Fiji and the Cook Islands, providing a broader South Pacific experience. Both ships can access smaller ports due to their size, offering intimate encounters with local culture and pristine nature that larger ships cannot.

🎭 Activities & Entertainment

Paul Gauguin notably features authentic Polynesian dance shows, language lessons, and local art workshops as integral parts of the cruise price, fostering a deep cultural connection. Their onboard dive program, complete with PADI certification opportunities, is a significant draw for scuba enthusiasts. Windstar also provides enriching activities, including local performances and some unique shore excursions (though these often come with additional fees). While Windstar’s focus is on relaxation and destination immersion rather than lively nightlife, Paul Gauguin offers a slightly more vibrant cultural program thanks to the Les Gauguines. Both offer a watersports platform at the stern for direct access to the sea, allowing for complimentary activities like kayaking, paddleboarding, and snorkeling in pristine lagoons.

📊 Pros & Cons

✔️ Windstar Star Breeze

• ✅ Spacious cabins: All-suite accommodations offer ample living space.
• ✅ Relaxed, yacht-like atmosphere: Intimate and uncrowded feel.
• ✅ Flexible itineraries with rare stops: Access to off-the-beaten-path islands like the Marquesas.
• ✅ Excellent dining quality: Highly rated cuisine, especially special events like deck barbecues.
• ❌ No true balconies on most cabins: Primarily French balconies or large windows.
• ❌ Less included in base fare: Drinks, Wi-Fi, and gratuities are typically extra.

✔️ Paul Gauguin Cruises

• ✅ Private balconies on most cabins: Ideal for private outdoor relaxation.
• ✅ Authentic Polynesian vibe: Enhanced by the “Les Gauguines” cultural hostesses.
• ✅ True all-inclusive luxury: Most expenses, including drinks and Wi-Fi, are covered.
• ✅ Onboard scuba dive program: A major plus for diving enthusiasts.
• ✅ Broader itineraries: Often include Fiji and the Cook Islands.
• ❌ Smaller cabins: Generally less interior space than Windstar.
• ❌ Higher base prices: Reflects the extensive all-inclusive nature.

🤔 Who Should Choose Which?

• Choose Windstar Star Breeze if you prioritize **more space in your cabin**, appreciate a relaxed, yacht-like ambiance, desire flexible excursions, and prefer a lower upfront price where you can customize your inclusions. It’s perfect for independent travelers, couples, and explorers who value a high degree of personalization.
• Choose Paul Gauguin Cruises if you value **true all-inclusive luxury**, desire a private balcony on your cabin, seek an **immersive local cultural experience**, and don’t mind paying a higher premium for a seamless, virtually cashless experience. It’s ideal for those looking for a fully pampered and culturally rich journey with a strong focus on water activities, especially scuba diving.

❓ FAQ: South Pacific Luxury Cruise Comparison

Is tipping included on these cruises?

A: On Windstar, gratuities are generally not included in the base fare (unless part of a specific promotional package). On Paul Gauguin, gratuities for all shipboard staff are included in your cruise fare, simplifying your experience.

Are alcoholic drinks included in the fare?

A: On Windstar, alcoholic drinks are typically an extra cost, though beverage packages can be purchased. On Paul Gauguin, a wide selection of alcoholic beverages, including fine wines, spirits, and beers, are included in your all-inclusive fare.

Is Wi-Fi included onboard?

A: On Windstar, Wi-Fi is usually an additional cost. On Paul Gauguin, basic Wi-Fi access is included for all guests, though speeds can vary in remote areas.

Which cruise offers better shore excursions?

A: Both lines offer high-quality shore excursions tailored to their destinations. Windstar is often praised for its unique, off-the-beaten-path stops and flexible excursion options. Paul Gauguin excels with a broader range of included water activities and a dedicated onboard dive program, making it superb for marine enthusiasts.

Do these cruises cater to families with children?

A: Both Windstar and Paul Gauguin primarily cater to adult travelers, couples, and older teens. They do not have extensive children’s programs or facilities found on larger, more family-oriented cruise lines. If traveling with young children, you might find options limited.

🏁 Final Thoughts

Both Windstar Star Breeze and Paul Gauguin Cruises deliver an unforgettable Tahiti experience, offering distinct approaches to luxury cruising in one of the world’s most beautiful regions. Your ultimate choice should be based on your preference for cabin space versus comprehensive all-inclusive amenities, and the type of cultural vibe you’re after—whether it’s Windstar’s yacht-like intimacy or Paul Gauguin’s authentic Polynesian immersion. Whichever you choose, you’re guaranteed to sail through paradise and create lifelong memories. The South Pacific awaits!

Which luxury cruise line would you choose for your Tahiti adventure?

💬 Share your opinion in the comments below and help others pick the perfect Tahiti cruise! 🌴✨